Newsworthy
James Sime has returned to his column, The Comic Pimp, at CBR for several weeks to discuss the next level of comic retailing. You can read the first installment by clicking the post title.
If you're not familiar with who James Sime is, he is the owner of the Isotope Lounge in San Francisco, CA, an innovative comic shop that takes, in his words, a "gonzo" approach to comic retailing (how could I not love it!). The Isotope's website lists all the crazy things they do from live events to DVD screenings, etc. It's over the top and highly successful. Check it out: www.isotopecomics.com
I tried to email Mr. Sime to get him to check out Chuck Kennedy's Retail Therapy column and give some feedback, but the email bounced unfortunately. I for one would love to hear his thoughts on Chuck's great ideas.
Another column of particular interest was this week's One Fan's Opinion by Erik Larsen, also at CBR. This week he talked about how to break in...sort of.
Now usually I like Erik's column, unlike some people I know. Usually he has interesting, insightful and fun stuff to talk about. A few weeks ago he wrote one about breaking in as well, but it wasn't received too well. I understand where he was going with the tone he used, but some just thought it was condescending crap.
This week's column, in my opinion is just that; condescending crap! First of all, he hasn't really told anyone reading this column anything they didn't already know. The whole column was basically "if you want to write or draw comics, just do it". Well duh! Then he proceeds to tell us if we can write but can't draw try it anyway because someone will read it, even if it's just family. But whatever you do don't send your crap to him because he doesn't want to read it!
Now as the publisher of one of the top four or five comic companies, Image Comics, that prides itself on creator owned projects and the best deal for them in the business, this statement utterly baffles me.
But to play devil's advocate for a second, I realize that Image and every other comic company receives tons of submissions all the time, and 90% of them are total crap. I get that. But when he says, and I quote (expletives paraphrased):
"You can do it.
If you want to make it in the funnybook field you should do it.
And when you're all done...think about me.
But do me a favor, okay? Don't send it to me. Lord knows I don't want to look at your wretched sh--."
That doesn't say to me that if it's crap or really amateur don't send it. It says to me I don't want to see your work unless your freakin' Warren Ellis or Jim Lee!
So what does that say about Image? Obviously they DO publish stuff by unknowns, but maybe they're gravitating away from this. Recently they have published books by Warren Ellis, Thomas Jane & Steve Niles, Jay Faerber, Todd Nauck and others. Sure, for every one of these there are two or three from lesser knowns, so I'll give them that.
It's just this statement hit me the wrong way. I'm willing to consider he didn't mean it as it was said as Larsen has always come off cold and arrogant in anything he's written. Still, I think he would be better served to read through his columns before posting them and actually think about what he's saying.
I'll put it like this. If I were in a position where I could influence tons of aspiring comic creators I would do everything I could to help them better themselves and produce top notch stuff, whether that be advice in a column or some other form of hands on help. I would not speak down to them and crush their hopes in a single blow. That's what I feel this column will do to those not strong enough to look past it. Fortunately I'm not one of those people!
B-Out








